How The Tudors Lost Their Heads – Episode 5


(c) Disney Plus


Episode Highlights

22 August 1553

Dan Snow – Today has been set for the execution of John Dudley, Duke of Northumberland. A month ago, he was the most powerful main in England. Now he’s led from the Tower of London to Tower Hill to face his fate.

Charged with launching a failed plot to put his own daughter-in-law, Lady Jane Grey, on the English throne…A Traitor, despised throughout the land as the ‘Wicked Duke.’

Was Dudley responsible for his own demise? Or was he a victim of the fickle and dangerous Tudor Court?


(c) Disney Plus



Dan Snow – We’re starting our investigation, here in its chapel, St Peter ad Vincula. in where his remains now lie.


(c) Disney Plus


Suzannah Lipscomb – He is the most important Tudor you have never heard of. He starts off without a title; he becomes the Duke of Northumberland and then he’s executed for treason.

He’s accused of trying to change the royal succession. So Henry VIII’s son, Edward who was King Edward VI, when he died at the age 0f 15, arguable his elder sister Mary should have inherited the throne. But Dudley is accused of trying to manipulate Edward to put his own daughter-in-law, Lady Jane Grey, on the throne instead.

And so, it is almost as if he is trying to create a new royal dynasty, a House of Dudley.

Dan Snow – But it wasn’t to be, was it. Dudley and most people associated, they go to the executioner’s block, and Mary’s gonna go on the throne.

Suzannah Lipscomb – So was Dudley a victim of brutal Tudor politics or out to steal the throne for himself?


(c) Disney Plus



In the spring of 1553 a shadow hung over England. The 15-year-old king, Edward VI, was gravely ill and seemed unlikely to recover. Without children of his own, his half-sister Mary looked set to inherit the throne

Then, in the last months of his life, Edward prepared an explosive document, now kept at Inner Temple Library in London. It sets out his dying wishes. This scrap of paper is one of the most important documents of the Tudor century, and it is astonishingly rare.

It was written by a 15-year-old king in his own hand, Edward VI. He calls it ‘My devise for the succession.’


(c) Disney Plus


…It is extraordinary for it rules out by not mentioning them his half-sisters Mary and Elizabeth. Mary in part because she is Catholic, but also because he considers both her and Elizabeth to be illegitimate.


(c) Disney Plus


(c) Disney Plus


But he has another concern as well. He repeatedly says that it should go to an heir male. He wants there to be a man on the throne after him, because of course there has been no ruling queen before this point….to the Lady Jane’s heir’s male…but not to Jane herself, her heir’s male.

But what is really interesting is that the document gets changed. Maybe this happens as Edward is close to dying, he makes an absolutely vital change. He crosses out the ‘S’ at the end of Lady Jane and adds in ‘and her,’ which changes the whole meaning of it. Suddenly he is not nominating a boy because Jane doesn’t have sons. He’s nominating Lady Jane and her heir’s male, putting Lady Jane Grey in the line of succession.


(c) Disney Plus


This choice was shocking. Some thought King Edward had been manipulated into this alteration. His close advisor, John Dudley, was their prime suspect.

Joanne Paul – So this becomes public knowledge in June, and a month before this Lady Jane Grey becomes Lady Jane Dudley. She marries one of the sons of John Dudley, and so to everyone seeing this, they’re realizing that this document puts John Dudley’s son on the throne of England, so of course they’re going to assume he had something to do with it.


(c) Disney Plus


Suzannah Lipscomb – It’s tempting to think that through his daughter-in-law Lady Jane Grey, Dudley was trying to create his own royal dynasty but that may not be the case. It was the dying king himself who presented this document to his chief justices, threatening to charge anyone who refused it with treason. And while the devise benefited Dudley, it ultimately put him in the firing line.

Joanne Paul – It’s a bit of a poison chalice because he’s now defending this new succession that goes against Henry VIII’s will. Shows him to perhaps be a manipulator in this, to be the one who’s setting all of this up, and he really doesn’t have a legal leg to stand on other than it being the will of the king.

Suzannah Lipscomb – Within a few days the devise was signed by the council and awaited final approval by Parliament.

Dan Snow – On the 6th of July, 1553, King Edward VI died. And whether or not Dudley had masterminded the succession plan himself, three days later he summoned his daughter-in-law Lady Jane Grey here, to Syon House.


(c) Disney Plus


Jane was led into this very room by Dudley, and what she found there shocked her to the core. The court was assembled. The courtiers dropped to their knees, and she was told that she would be queen. She was overwhelmed at the news, some sources say she even fainted. When she came to, she said defiantly, ‘The crown is not mine by right. It pleases me not. Mary is the rightful heir.”

But Jane had no choice and Dudley moved fast to make the succession happen.


(c) Disney Plus


Suzannah Lipscomb – The idea was to keep the king’s death and Jane’s succession a secret until Mary could be captured. But things didn’t go according to plan.

Mary fled to her house in Norfolk. She clearly knew something was afoot.

This (letter) is sent on the very day that Dudley tells Jane that she is queen. And it starts with expressing her great grief and heaviness of heart at the news that ‘The king, our dearest brother and late sovereign lord is departed to God upon Thursday last at night.’

So, although Dudley and the council have tried to hold back this information from her, she has evidently learnt that this has happened. And then it goes on the defensive, it becomes very powerful.

She sets out her right to the crown, ‘of this realm of England…is justly come unto us by God’s new providence’ and is signed ‘Mary the quene.’

Mary then order’s the council to defend her, their rightful queen, at any cost.

This is Mary blindsiding Dudley and the council. But Dudley was not prepared to roll over.


(c) Disney Plus


Dan Snow – Five days later and seemingly with the support of the council he left London with 1,500 men to capture Mary. Dudley was heading here, Framlingham Castle. Once owned by the Duke of Norfolk, it was given to Mary when he was imprisoned. And here, she was mustering her troops to try and seize the crown.

So Mary has come to this powerful stronghold, she’s building up her forces, has Dudley still got the whip hand or is he in trouble?

Nicola Tallis – That is the million-dollar question, because really to begin with all of the odds seem to be very much stacked in Jane and Dudley’s favour. He has got London at his command. He has got arms and ammunition, but he has not banked on the fact that Mary is going to come here.

She is actually incredibly popular here in East Anglia, and men really do flock to her banner day by day, as many as apparently 20,000 in the end…She’s popular, she’s well loved, she is Henry VIII’s daughter. Everyone wants to see her restored to her birthright

Dan Snow – By contrast, Dudley was loathed in this part of England, having put down riots here. And as Dudley drew nearer to Framlingham even his own men began to desert him.

Worse still back in London, Dudley’s enemies were turning the whole council against him and Jane.

So tell me about the showdown, what happens when Dudley actually arrives here?


(c) Disney Plus


Nicola Tallis – He doesn’t, there’s no showdown. It all ends before any swords have clashed.

Dan Snow – On 19th July 1553, before Dudley could reach Framlingham, the council in London proclaimed Mary the new queen. Dudley tried to swear his allegiance to her, but it was too late.

Suzannah Lipscomb – On the 18th of August 1553, John Dudley, was brought here to Westminster Hall to face trial…Dudley was accused of raising troops against Mary and declaring Jane queen in her place. All true. But in Dudley’s mind this wasn’t an open and shut case.


(c) Disney Plus



He doesn’t deny any of the charges, but what he does say is “whether any man doing this by the authority of the council and by warrant of the great seal of England could be charged with treason.” His point is, if he had done otherwise, that would have been treason, and he also points out that many of the people who were judging him at this point were equally culpable. They too had been in on the succession of Jane and committed to it.’

He even converts to Catholicism at the end…But I don’t really know if he was hoping to save himself or just hoping to save his family.


(c) Disney Plus


Dan Snow – Do you think he had monarchical ambitions? His eye on the throne?

Suzannah Lipscomb – I don’t think so. I think that the Devise for the Succession was Edward’s idea. And you have to remember that everyone of importance signs up to Edward’s Devse for the Succession. It’s not just Dudley. But I suppose what his life and death tells us is exactly the price that’s paid if you want to rise at the Tudor Court, you have to be prepared to fall.

Dan Snow – Dudley had gone from an outcast to the very top of society. He had been loyal to three monarchs, but ultimately, he overplayed his hand.